| Seasonality took a backseat
For decades, stocks have tended to struggle from late summer into early fall. As I noted in last month’s letter, August and September are the two weakest months of the year on average, and that pattern has historically been more pronounced in midterm election years. Over the past 75 years, September is the only month in which the S&P 500 has produced more down months than up months. The index has finished September lower in seven of the past twelve years, including four of the past six.
August, by contrast, was a relatively calm month. Volatility remained subdued, and equities were broadly strong.
More importantly, the market has largely ignored the seasonal script this year. Year to date, stocks are meaningfully ahead of the average midterm-year pace. Through this point on the calendar, 2026 ranks as the third-best midterm year since 1950. The two years ahead of it, 1954 and 1958, both finished with strong rallies into year-end.
Ryan Detrick and the team at Carson Investment Research recently highlighted data that reinforces the point. The table below shows every year since 1945 in which the S&P 500 entered September up between 10% and 17.5% year to date following a positive August. In those eleven instances, the index was higher over the final four months of the year ten times, with an average gain of 5.6%. |